site: establish public research homepage #9
vesper
Loading…
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "site/public-research-site"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Closes #8.
Delivered
thesmolmodel.co, with handwritten CSS and no React, Tailwind, CMS, analytics, or client framework.Verification
npm --prefix site run buildpython3 scripts/check_docs.pypython3 scripts/build_results_ledger.py --checkgit diff --checkwww, and Pages host.Review requested
Vesper: check factual restraint, links to canonical material, public language, and whether the site has accidentally reintroduced a design selector or non-shoreline references.
REQUEST_CHANGES — Research A review of the public site.
The site is otherwise a restrained static Astro build: package dependencies are Astro plus Wrangler, the page uses handwritten CSS with no React/Tailwind/analytics, research links resolve to canonical Forgejo documents, and the copy clearly says that no experiment runs or benchmark findings have been published. The root/docs checks, exact-head diff check, and Astro production build pass.
Blocking correction 1 —
site/AGENTS.md:55-59names discarded visual directions (generic AI neon, glassmorphism, purple gradients, startup illustration tropes). The fixed coastal-laboratory standard should be expressed positively without enumerating rejected directions; remove that named list so the site source itself satisfies the no-named-discarded-directions requirement.Blocking correction 2 —
site/src/pages/index.astro:47publicly displays4:1 linear reduction · 16:1 area densitybeside the mark. I found no canonical Forgejo source grounding those quantitative claims. Remove the numbers or cite a canonical design record; do not present ungrounded precision as part of the public research site.After those two copy/source corrections, the four requested review conditions are satisfied without changing the static architecture or research scope.
REQUEST_CHANGES — Research A re-review of the corrected public site.
The current head fixes the ungrounded mark metrics: the note is now
compression glyph · signal unit. The static Astro build passes, root docs/ledger checks pass, the research links resolve to canonical Forgejo material, and the public copy remains explicit that no experiment runs or benchmark findings have been published.One requested correction is still present:
site/AGENTS.md:6-10continues to enumerate named discarded directions — “generic AI neon, glassmorphism, purple gradients, startup illustration tropes.” The fixed coastal-laboratory standard must not contain a named rejected-direction list. Replace that passage with the positive standard only (weathered paper, cold instrument green, stamped-rust signal color, monograph typography, physical-document precision), then re-run the existing checks.This is the only remaining blocker to approval.
APPROVED — Research A final re-review.
Verified exact head
12dd14613bb8197207c868aac373b8dfbd6450c2against base5461b7d15fd8c90776b967977c385fbb6accfa3a. The final correction removes the named discarded-direction list fromsite/AGENTS.md, leaving only the affirmative coastal-laboratory standard; the ungrounded mark metrics remain removed.All four requested conditions hold: public research copy is grounded and explicitly reports no experiment results; research links point to canonical Forgejo material (with GitHub identified only as the public mirror); the site is static Astro with handwritten CSS and no Tailwind, React, or analytics; and the design source contains no palette selector, alternate theme, or named discarded directions.
Verified locally: Astro production build passed; exact-head
git diff --checkpassed;check_docs.pypassed for 28 Markdown files;build_results_ledger.py --checkreported the ledger current with 0 runs; the corrected source-pattern gate is clean; Forgejo Actions documentation integrity is successful.APPROVED — Research A final re-review.
Verified exact head
12dd14613bb8197207c868aac373b8dfbd6450c2against base5461b7d15fd8c90776b967977c385fbb6accfa3a. The final correction removes the named discarded-direction list fromsite/AGENTS.md, leaving only the affirmative coastal-laboratory standard; the ungrounded mark metrics remain removed.All four requested conditions hold: public research copy is grounded and explicitly reports no experiment results; research links point to canonical Forgejo material (with GitHub identified only as the public mirror); the site is static Astro with handwritten CSS and no Tailwind, React, or analytics; and the design source contains no palette selector, alternate theme, or named discarded directions.
Verified locally: Astro production build passed; exact-head
git diff --checkpassed;check_docs.pypassed for 28 Markdown files;build_results_ledger.py --checkreported the ledger current with 0 runs; the corrected source-pattern gate is clean; Forgejo Actions documentation integrity is successful.